1,000 years ago, the ocean was full of giants.
CLICKING
Whales were so numerous
that they shaped how the ocean worked.
They even affected the land.
BIRDSONG
The evidence is written into their behaviour,
their character, their communities
and the world that formed around them.
The clues are everywhere.
We must deduce how many whales there once were...
..and what happened to them.
It's time for them to tell their story.
It's said that the ocean has no memory.
The tragedies in its depths and the daily dramas of its creatures
seem swept away, leaving no record.
But the ocean doesn't forget.
It bears witness to a past.
We just have to know...
..where to look.
To a blue whale, the world is a small place.
They are the largest animal that has ever lived.
They travel to ancestral feeding grounds,
carrying the instincts and memories of the riches of the sea.
Clouds of shrimp-like krill
emerge from under the ice around Antarctica.
A tongue the size of an elephant
pushes 100 tonnes of water through their baleen.
A quarter of a ton of krill
goes down a throat that you could fit a car through.
The great whales could have been rare, as they are now,
but there is evidence that they recently dominated the ocean.
A keystone species affecting everything,
living in vast numbers.
To understand the link between whales
and the health of the underwater world,
we need to find clues as to how many there once were.
And crucially, how many disappeared.
PULSED CALLS
Bowhead whales are Arctic specialists.
But 150 years ago, they had almost all gone.
They have huge heads for breaking through
half-metre-thick ice to breathe.
If any whale could remember the past, it's a bowhead.
Bowheads are the longest-living mammals,
up to about 260 years.
One of these could have been born before Napoleon Bonaparte
or the Declaration of Independence.
Their history is written under their skin.
A few bowheads carry harpoons from two centuries ago.
Aboriginal walrus-ivory weapons have been found,
and metal harpoons with patents and dates.
Inside is a brain double the size of ours.
Equally complex.
It would be surprising if memories didn't affect their behaviour.
To know what to look for,
we need to understand what they went through.
Their future arrived in thousands of ships 200 years ago.
They were crewed by tough men and boys.
FAINT CHATTER
Harpooned, the whales would try to escape
and the little boats were towed along with them -
known as a Nantucket sleighride.
Yankee whalers out of Nantucket
harvested enough oil to light every American home.
By 1900, steamboats with exploding harpoons had changed everything.
Whaling was industrialised.
Processing plants led to factory ships.
Able to take in a day what traditional whalers took in a year.
By 1930, 90% of bowheads were gone,
with survivors hiding in isolated pockets.
Many other whales suffered the same fate.
100 years ago, a tiny population of southern right whales
held out in the South Atlantic.
On the Patagonian coast of Argentina,
in bays sheltered by the Peninsula Valdes,
there is a sanctuary.
The southern right whales still come here, because it is safe.
Like blue whales and bowheads,
they carry clues to the past.
Their faces have hard patches called callosities.
They may help to fight off rival males.
Useful in a sea full of whales.
They are also home to a unique community of lice.
Whales play host to many specialist species,
and that only happens if there are plenty of whales to act as hosts.
This is a nursery.
Their young are born here.
Only a handful of these whales survive,
so a genetic bottleneck with some inbreeding is to be expected.
These days, one in six calves born here are white.
Tiny populations often throw up genetic abnormalities.
Whaling may have changed the shade of this pale whale.
His testimony is in the colour of his skin.
The backs of the whales are pockmarked,
where gulls have pecked at their skin as they surface to breathe.
Whales may have fed a lot of other unlikely animals in the past.
The whales soon figured out ways to outwit the birds.
The mothers bend their backs down,
called a galleon position.
The whales' brainpower on show
points towards them being part of an adaptable and sophisticated society.
The calves stay close to the mothers,
but amorous males and teenagers often want to join in.
They push the calf aside and try to climb on top of the mother.
Right whales are very buoyant, so it's a struggle.
Most of the time, it's not about reproduction.
Whales are very tactile.
They embrace face-to-face.
They are slow breeders.
In a world full of whales, that helps,
but now it's a disadvantage.
Whalers called them right whales
because they were the right whales to kill.
They are slow and float once dead.
Right whale hunting was banned in the 1930s
and they started to recover.
By the 1960s, their numbers should have risen to hundreds, at least.
Whale scientist Bob Brownell was part of a 1969 expedition
to document and film their successful recovery.
They searched the coast of South America,
but couldn't find any right whales.
That was not what they expected.
Then they came to a bay behind the Peninsula Valdes.
It was just, er... You know, it looked like a very desolated place.
Eventually, a handful of whales emerge,
like victims of a disaster.
And we found, I don't remember, half-a-dozen or eight whales,
and then we didn't encounter them again.
The rest had vanished.
The memory of the almost-empty bay preoccupies Bob Brownell.
And 25 years later, he still wants the truth.
There must have been somebody who witnessed this crime.
IN RUSSIAN:
When there's a cover-up, documents are destroyed,
but rarely all of them.
Bob Brownell asked Yablokov for help.
On one of the factory ships was a young scientist,
Yuri Mikhalev, who was collecting data.
In the '60s, he was based in Odesa,
working on the whaling data from the South Atlantic.
IN RUSSIAN:
Mikhalev hid the stolen records,
photographs, newspapers
and even an old Soviet newsreel showing the whaling flotilla.
These are his original records,
made while on a Soviet factory ship,
the Sovetskaya Ukraina.
A 13m whale was processed in 90 minutes.
The records are detailed -
location, age, sex and weight.
From discovering how many died, we can work backwards
to uncover how many whales there once were.
It's gone from hundreds to tens of thousands.
If whales lived in such huge numbers,
you'd expect clues on the coast,
as well as in the ocean.
Many whales, when they die, end up on the beach.
40 tonnes of food brings life to the land.
California condors are rare,
but nobody considered that a land-based bird
might eat so much whale.
Yet tests on a 200-year-old museum specimen
revealed whale isotopes in its bones.
If whales really predominated in the sea,
in places, there would have been dead whales every few kilometres.
For any coastal animals, whales were likely to be a key food.
Polar and grisly bears living near the coast
evolved to be bigger than mountain or forest bears,
probably because they had whales to eat.
And without beached whales, the lean years are tougher.
And now, there are fewer bears.
Occasionally, we glimpse what it could have been like.
A single whale feeds animals over a wide area,
and lots of bears come to the picnic.
Whales would have fed us, too.
Early humans spread around the globe, following coastlines.
It's possible that we were only able to cross into North America
by surviving on whales.
If the influence of whales on land is significant,
imagine the effects in the ocean.
Picture the sea thousands of years ago.
As well as many more whales,
the oceans had ten times more fish.
With more plankton, more food, more everything.
No one thing seems to have caused the collapse.
The ocean works as a single system.
It is more interconnected than the land.
Animals here depend on each other in unexpected ways.
A keystone species is one that, if it goes...
..its place isn't filled by others.
Rather, the loss cascades through the whole ecosystem,
like a building losing its foundations.
Knowing about whales, we can look for clues
as to what has happened to the oceans, and why.
Most of the ocean is desert,
with life congregating around shallow water
or nutrient-rich currents.
It has seasons and cycles
that we are only now beginning to understand.
PULSED CALLS
Whales migrate around the planet,
guided by past memories
and instincts of where and when food gathers.
PULSED CALLS
These humpback whales
travel to the Eastern Pacific in search of anchovies.
GULLS CRY
Humpbacks work together,
eating millions of anchovies each day.
Most of the fish escape.
If they didn't, there would be nothing next year.
Whales and fish evolve together.
They balance each other.
If the whales don't come,
anchovy numbers explode,
and then they eat more plankton.
And when that runs out anchovy numbers crash,
leaving seals, birds and other fish to starve.
Everything is connected.
The whales from the Southern Ocean move north,
towards the tropics, to give birth and mate.
On the way, they pass through the Cook Strait
that separates the North and South Islands of New Zealand.
For 200 years, small shore-based
whaling stations lined the coast.
But by the 1950s, only the Tory channel station remained,
and was celebrated.
Dividing New Zealand in two halves is Cook Strait.
And at its narrowest part, only 12 miles separates
the North Island from the South.
Looking out over its waters are men of the Tory Channel
whaling station, searching for whales.
From each of these 40 or 50-tonne creatures
will come up to six tonnes of oil.
Oil valuable in the making of margarine and other foods.
We had records of all the whales we'd seen, the whales we'd caught.
Everything we saw, we recorded.
Peter Perano remembers 1959 and '60.
One year, they were all over the place,
and then they just dropped straight off within two years.
It hit us just like that.
Yeah, it was quick. It was really quick.
And, er...they were...they were gone.
It was a mystery, and there were suspicions.
But New Zealand whalers told themselves
that the humpbacks had maybe found a different migration route.
But thousands of whales can't just disappear.
Alexey Yablokov knew the truth.
And in 1993, he set up a network of scientists
to find any original documents not destroyed.
As a young man, Dmitry Tormosov,
like Yuri Mikhalev,
was responsible for monitoring catches
onboard Soviet factory ships.
IN RUSSIAN:
Blue, humpback, sperm whales.
One season, one expedition.
One page for each whale.
HE SIGHS
By the 1970s, the Soviet whaling flotillas had to be invisible.
Meanwhile, the anti-whaling movement was pushing for a ban on whaling.
People were risking their lives to protect the whales.
Protests focused around the International Whaling Commission,
or IWC.
You're standing up for
what you know is right...!
THEY CHANT
..and say no more whaling,
no more whaling ever!
Governments send representatives to a meeting each year
to negotiate whaling quotas.
Without rules and regulations
to provide for the proper conservation of whale stock,
and the orderly development...
SPEAKING RUSSIAN:
Every whale has a different history.
Grey whales tell their own story.
They migrate from Mexico to Alaska,
staying close to the shore.
They suck the sand from the seabed and filter it for shrimp or feed
on mysids and kelp beds.
This way they're not competing with a sea full of other whales
looking for krill or anchovies.
There's another theory as to why they stay near the shore.
A large number of grey whales would have attracted predators,
and shallow water is safer.
It's hard to imagine anything hunting a grey whale...
..but in fact, their predators are still out there...
..killer whales, or orcas.
They attack many different whales and work as a team.
CLICKING
Almost every whale has adapted to deal with orcas.
A whale's huge size may have evolved in response.
The killers approach silently from behind.
They're not whales, but giant dolphins.
The orca's strategy is to drown the calf.
They want to eat its tongue.
It's their favourite bit - a delicacy.
The battle is finely balanced,
as it would be if they evolved
together in large numbers.
These are old enemies from an ocean of giants.
The baby has several instinctive strategies.
He spins his body and tries to hide
his head on his mother's back.
The mother has other tricks.
She tries to put her body
in the way of the orcas.
She slaps at the orcas
with her tail.
The calf and mother use every
strategy to fend off the orcas.
Though the calf isn't seriously
injured, the battle seems lost.
But the mother and calf's defences are well-practised.
It's extraordinary.
The attack is over.
One orca gives the baby a gentle nudge,
eye to eye.
Hunter and hunted have evolved to understand each other.
Grey whales have also provided another piece of the puzzle.
An analysis of their DNA reveals an historic breeding group
of about 100,000 grey whales on the North American coast.
There were many other populations around the world,
now extinct.
Before whaling,
we can imagine an ocean of a million grey whales.
There's another species of whale that we know for sure was
once common - sperm whales.
Sperm whales were by far the most valuable.
In the 1850s, a single sperm whale was worth about $500,000
at today's prices.
As recently as the 1950s, there was still no substitute
for sperm oil, and it was used in cars and nuclear weapons.
For secret whalers, sperm whales were the jackpot.
CLICKING
Sperm whales are also perhaps
the whale most critical to the ocean.
They're a keystone species.
If you remove them, the destructive effects ripple out and the fragile
ecosystem wobbles and falls.
As they dive to hunt a kilometre down, we see the first clue
as to why they are so central to the story.
Faeces are released
and nutrients flood out.
It's what remains of food caught near the ocean floor.
This one effect is so great
that they provide nutrients
that bring life to whole areas of ocean.
It's called the whale pump.
Whales fertilise the oceans, moving
nutrients trapped far below
back towards the surface.
This is one of the few sources
of iron, essential for plankton.
Plankton is the ocean's nursery.
Baby fish, crabs and lobsters live for years in this miniature world.
Plankton comprises or feeds 80% of ocean life.
If whales are part of the system at all, we may be in trouble.
Plants called phytoplankton provide
half of the world's oxygen.
As iron levels fall,
the amounts of phytoplankton also fall.
Plankton and whales are linked
in other surprising ways.
We've discovered that phytoplankton,
like these diatoms, respond
to whale song.
WHALE SINGS
They are bioluminescent.
We don't know what the flashing means, but we're beginning
to imagine a world full of whale song...
..with the animals and plants responding,
feeding each other and depending on each other.
There's more.
A kilometre down
is a different world.
For a marine mammal to enter is extraordinary.
They hold their breath for an hour's dive.
Swarms of creatures emerge from the dark.
Huge squid, like these metre-long Humboldts,
feed on blind fish.
Sperm whales hunt giant squid 15m-long.
We can only imagine that battle.
CLICKING
Sperm whales hunt by echolocation.
They use a huge oil-filled lens on their heads to focus clicks
like a beam of light.
They listen to the reflections.
The bottom is a graveyard.
The majority of all the whales
that die end up down here.
This carcass is a young grey whale.
Feeding are moose octopuses,
ratfish, hogfish, tube worms and crabs.
The species that depended on whales
falling from above must be starving,
and many perhaps are now extinct.
The largest single ecosystem
on Earth is the deep ocean floor.
Whales are the ambassadors between one world and the other,
even in death.
CLICKING
Sperm whales are special in yet more ways.
They live in matriarchal families and communicate in one of the most
sophisticated animal languages.
We can even detect dialects between clans.
FAST CLICKING
They sometimes listen to each other with their mouths open.
Their jaw has hollow bones and acts as an amplifier.
Sperm whales have the largest brains on the planet,
six times the size of ours.
Intelligence must have been important in a richer,
more sophisticated world.
Now, with fewer whales, the nutrient whale pump is less effective.
The ocean floor is impoverished,
and diatoms flash,
but to ships and deep-sea drilling,
and the whale-sized hole has left a poorer ocean.
Sperm whales sleep.
We think that they dream, like us.
Nightmares are full of memories.
The older whales have witnessed
traumatic change.
Whales value their family and gather
attentively around the baby.
CLICKING
Childhood can last a decade,
adults passing on skills and knowledge that define
their whale culture.
Cubs have to come up for air more often,
so here in the North Pacific, whalers would just wait.
CLICKING
They'd harpoon her, and the whole family would
come to the surface to help.
They'd never leave an injured baby.
They'd all be killed.
The records of the number of sperm whales illegally killed
are the hardest to find.
Soviet whaling in the North Pacific was based in Vladivostok,
with any information locked in state archives.
Heading there, undercover, is a young academic
called Yulia Ivashchenko.
The idea was to search archives and find the available information
in Vladivostok, and in particular sperm whales.
It just was astonishing because I was sure that most
of these records were destroyed.
I would order as many reports every day as possible, because I stayed
there for months and I'll just copy and copy and copy and copy
and copy. Because it was done pretty quietly without letting
the librarian know, because they could question -
why would I do copies of the whole reports?
What emerges from thousands of hidden documents is that whales
were taken in huge numbers, with their location, sizes, weights
and ages all recorded.
In the North Pacific alone,
25,000 sperm whales were killed
and processed in secret.
An untold personal story emerges, too,
of individual people and whales.
At the same time, the International Whaling Commission was trying
to impose quotas and inspect the Soviet whalers.
IN RUSSIAN:
The story moves from Russia to Japan.
IN RUSSIAN:
At the IWC, the Japanese said that they caught large males
within the quota.
The Vladivostok archive proved that was impossible.
The Soviets never saw large males.
The Japanese were handing in clumsy lies.
All of the big old males had been taken years earlier.
Scattered families were all that remained.
The IWC conference in 2018 turned out to be the showdown.
The Japanese want to return to commercial whaling.
Our evidence of falsified Japanese documents was presented
to the head of the Japanese delegation and chair
of the IWC, Joji Morishita.
IN ENGLISH:
Since the moratorium on commercial whaling in 1986,
the IWC has struggled to achieve more.
But now, here, in 2018, a new proposal is set to reshape the IWC
to protect whales.
The Japanese want to stop it.
What happens next will play out in a day or so.
Part of the debate is that there is good news for whales.
Humpback numbers have recovered worldwide to about 150,000.
The whalers overlooking the Cook Strait witnessed one
of the worst massacres.
They are still looking for their whales.
Like the International Whaling Commission, they, too, have turned
to protecting the whales that they hunted
when they were young.
I see something,
right in line with that bloody...
Boat out here.
Oh, that white water?
Yeah, white water, that's the whale.
A few humpbacks are returning.
Oh, yeah, breaching! There he is.
Wow!
SHE LAUGHS
Communities now make more money whale watching than whale killing.
But numbers are building more slowly here than elsewhere.
THEY GASP
There is something about witnessing
an animal doing well
that enriches all of us.
After travelling through the Cook Strait, the whales move
on to their breeding grounds in the Tropical Pacific.
WHALE SONG
Here, they sing.
SINGING CONTINUES
Mothers come here to give birth in warm, protected waters.
Like the right whales of Patagonia,
this is their sanctuary.
The positive influence of the whales is beginning to reach out,
and life responds.
It's shocking to uncover
that we slaughtered about 4 million
of these magnificent creatures.
And as the oceanic system weakened,
we lost many more.
It will take centuries of careful
support and protection
for their numbers to build back up,
but it will be worth it.
Not long ago, whale song must have filled the ocean,
yet it is a song that is not always heard.
Japan carries out their threat to leave
the International Whaling Commission.
In the winter of 2019, the Japanese
drop any pretence of only whaling
for scientific purposes, and that summer return
to commercial whaling in their territorial waters.
We'll never know for sure how many whales they'll catch.
The ocean was built around whales, millions of whales,
and as they decline, everything suffers.
The investigation, the behaviour and the data have concluded
that 4 million whales were killed
out of 5 million alive 300 years ago.
Before then, there must
have been many, many more.
Whales have witnessed one of mankind's most senseless crimes.
What is extraordinary
is that sometimes they choose
to trust us.
We continue to destroy the ocean
that they were a part of creating,
but there is a fresh generation of whales, and people.
One day, we may live to earn their trust.